Labour Party leader Keir Starmer has made yet another U-turn when he spoke out in favour of the first past the post electoral system:
When he was running for Labour leader, Keir Starmer made a passionate case for electoral reform.
Now he makes a passionate case for, wait for it… the first past the post system.
One of the most deceitful and unprincipled politicians of our age.pic.twitter.com/lqUq0LH242 https://t.co/NuOmYH97R1
— Owen Jones (@OwenJones84) June 27, 2024
Obviously, Starmer decided to go even further. Hilariously, he said the current electoral system has given us ‘strong government’. Which is a complete joke to anyone who hasn’t spent the last 14 years in a coma:
BREAKING: @Keir_Starmer reveals he thinks First Past the Post gave us the “strong government” of Johnson, Truss and Sunak, and is “not making any changes to it”.
Farage and Braverman will be laughing their heads off right now. 😳 pic.twitter.com/1riVYSwhXd
— GET PR DONE! ⭕️⚫️🟣🟢🔴🟠 (@getprdone) June 26, 2024
At a time when trust in politics is at a record low and it’s clear to millions of people that Westminster isn’t working, @Keir_Starmer has come out to defend our broken electoral system.
🧵 1/5 pic.twitter.com/SYXZj1DH6n
— LCER (@Labour4PR) June 26, 2024
Political jokes
Millions of voters have historically been misrepresented by the first-past-the-post system. In three of the last five general elections, 50% of the votes went to losing candidates. This is down to MP’s being elected with very small vote shares when there are three or more candidates standing in one area. This means that at the 2019 general election, 71% of votes were wasted:
The only people who like first past the post are politicians who win by first past the post https://t.co/yfYiri0g2i pic.twitter.com/vWNJbhhEAi
— Left Of London (@Left_Of_London) June 27, 2024
#DontTrustKeir. Any person that says that First Past The Post is the right electoral system is lying to you.
79% (seventy nine percent!) of all votes casted in the 2019 General Election has no impact in the final result.
We need #ProportionalRepresentation now.#VoteGreen https://t.co/XFQ8VxFFdV— Rod Gonggrijp 🚴♂️ and 🌱 and 🇺🇦 (@LeFouPedalant) June 26, 2024
Tactical voting or shooting ourselves in the head?
In recent weeks, Labour has been encouraging people to vote tactically in order to keep the Tories out. According to the Guardian, tactical voting is set to be higher than ever before at this election. Previously, Lib Dem and Labour voters have often switched sides to get rid of the Tories. However, it seems this year that both parties are carrying out extremely specific campaigns. They are focusing on ousting as many Tories as possible.
By constantly asking for people to vote tactically, @UKLabour are acknowledging that there is a problem with our democracy
By refusing to reform our democracy, Labour are showing that they are part of that problem #VoteGreen https://t.co/W6YjIdcFZy
— Martin Farley🔰💚 (@martin_farley) June 27, 2024
The problem with tactical voting is that it forces voters to make a choice. One between who they really want to represent them, and someone who they don’t really like, in order to keep out whoever will fuck them over the most.
As Alex Rice said in 2015:
The sentiment of voting should be one of hope not negativity. It should be an act that gives people a stake in society and their community. It shouldn’t be a calculated decision or one that leaves you feeling uneasy on your way home. So here’s a simple message, vote for whoever you think would be your best local MP, then lobby them for change.
Back in October 2023 – which is less than a year ago – Labour adopted official policy which recognised that:
the flaws in the current voting system are contributing to the distrust and alienation we see in politics.
This came after the 2022 Labour Party conference which voted in favour of proportional representation at general elections. Notably, the majority of Labour members, Constituency Labour Parties, and over two thirds of affiliated trade unions all support electoral reform:
So Keir what precisely was the point of Labour conference voting overwhelmingly for PR?@MVM_Lewes @CompassLewes https://t.co/b03r1Odcqq
— Mark Perryman (@MarkPerryman) June 26, 2024
Just months ago his own policy programme officially recognised that the flawed First Past the Post system is driving “the distrust and alienation we see in politics”.
— LCER (@Labour4PR) June 26, 2024
How nonsensical.
And anti democratic as @UKLabour
conference voted to adopt PR.
If he won’t listen to his Party, why would he listen to anyone else? https://t.co/BFw41NTCtH— Jenny Jones (@GreenJennyJones) June 27, 2024
Starmer screwing with the electorate
Starmer and his leadership team are choosing to ignore the fact that the labour movement overwhelmingly endorses ditching first past the post and embracing a form of proportional representation. The Labour leadership refuses to represent the policies that its members have voted for.
A recent poll also showed that the British public more generally, albeit narrowly support a change to a more proportional voting system. This means that Starmer isn’t only ignoring Labour voters – but the public mood more generally.
I don’t know about anyone else, but all the U-turns are making me dizzy. Either Keir is the most indecisive man I’ve ever met, or he is purposefully screwing with every single member of the electorate:
Exactly this. They’re deliberately perpetuating a problem so that they can profit from it. At this point, it’s more of a protection racket than an electoral system fit for a serious democracy.
— Rosemary Sexton (@DrSextonGreen) June 27, 2024
This is the most cynical U-turn of all
Don’t vote tactically for Labour
Starmer has made it clear that he doesn’t care what you really believe in
He just cares about Labour having all the power, forever https://t.co/3w5arDMCBS
— Green💚🌻🍉Molly (@GreenPartyMolly) June 26, 2024
Importantly, the UK is the only democracy in Europe which still uses first past the post for its main elections. Meaning, it’s not the only way and we don’t have to remain trapped in a broken system:
Fun fact: Westminster elections and English & Welsh local council elections use the first past the post system.
Holyrood, the Sennedd, Stormont and Scottish & NI local council elections all use some form of proportional representation voting. https://t.co/whLjuH7gSh
— Sarah Mackie (@lumi_1984) June 27, 2024
The one thing that could have got me to vote Labour has just been ruled out.
If you believe in a strong democracy, if you believe that everyone’s vote should count, if you believe we should be able to vote positively rather than tactically – then DON’T VOTE LABOUR. https://t.co/PSdHoyK2jV
— Joy Of Zen Motoring (@JoyOfPedals) June 27, 2024
Ultimately, now the wind is blowing in Labour’s favour, Starmer is sticking to the familiar. Like many before him, he is willing to sell his soul for the capitalist establishment in order to get the keys for Number 10. Starmer’s Labour was never going to be the party of political reform.
Millions of voices don’t matter to Labour. While they might take power at the next election, they will not speak for the majority of the UK.
And as this guy put it:
Voting Labour for change is like putting on a new hat because you shat yourself.https://t.co/NxFUkdIndD
— Alan Ferrier (@alanferrier) June 26, 2024
Feature image via BBC News/YouTube